Gioiello wrote:dartraighe wrote:Gioiello
People still do not understand that there were no R1b nor R1a people in Siberia 13,000 ybp because they would have crossed the Bering Strait along with the Native American Q people. That could mean that the R1b lines that we see in the Steppe today came through the Balkans from the Villabruna R1b clan.
I think that the "American proof" isn't a proof, because Amerindians wintered in Beringia for thousands of years before migrating to America, it is possible that they reached America long before it is thought so far, and R1b could be amongst them and being went extinct etc etc. Only positive proof are valid. Anyway we'll see...
Some say that Villabruna is an extinct Y line in Italy and yet there are 15 million R1b males living there today. My point was that we are not descended from the Mal'ta boy clan. Furthermore, rumour has it, the BB paper will not be published for another two months. They must be having problems with the results.